Send email for updates


About updates
Research analysis

This entry is our analysis of a study considered particularly relevant to improving outcomes from drug or alcohol interventions in the UK. The original study was not published by Findings; click Title to order a copy. Free reprints may be available from the authors – click prepared e-mail. Links to other documents. Hover over for notes. Click to highlight passage referred to. Unfold extra text Unfold supplementary text The Summary conveys the findings and views expressed in the study. Below is a commentary from Drug and Alcohol Findings.

Title and link for copying Comment/query to editor

Syringe disposal bins: the outcomes of a free trial for city traders in an inner-city municipality Australia.

Devaney M., Berends L.
Substance Use and Misuse: 2008, 43(1), p. 139–153.
Unable to obtain a copy by clicking title? Try asking the author for a reprint by adapting this prepared e-mail or by writing to Dr Devaney at madonna.devaney@turningpoint.org.au. You could also try this alternative source.

What happens when city authorities ask retail and service premises to host syringe disposal bins in their toilets? There were misgivings, but when the bins meant customers and staff could avoid discarded syringes, they were welcomed and retained, safely disposing of over 2000 syringes a month.

Summary Community responses toward discarded syringes have the potential to threaten the sustainability of harm reduction interventions. Many retailers in the central business district of Melbourne, Australia, have expressed concern about drug use and the associated discarded syringes. Melbourne City Council has responded to these concerns through a variety of strategies. One such strategy was a six-month free trial of syringe bins for businesses during 2003–2004. The council commissioned an external evaluation of the trial. Eighteen business representatives and six key informants undertook semi-structured interviews to monitor issues arising throughout the trial. Syringe disposal bins are a useful option for facilitating appropriate syringe disposal; 11 of the 13 businesses which participated in the trial continued with the maintenance of the syringe disposal bins beyond the free trial period.


Findings logo commentary Melbourne syringe disposal binSyringe disposal units sited in public toilets and other publicly controlled facilities are not uncommon in Britain, but units sited on private premises are. When Melbourne sought to broaden access to disposal facilities, it took the unusual step of canvassing toilet-equipped city centre business and leisure premises Including restaurants, cafés, cinemas, department stores, theatres, gyms and fitness centres. as well as hospitals, colleges, churches and welfare groups, offering free installation and servicing of bins. Over the six months of the trial, 62 bins were installed and some existing bins began to be properly serviced, accounting for an estimated 12,590 syringes. After the trial period, nine of the 11 businesses involved took on the costs of continuing to service 58 bins. Motivating their involvement was typically concern that customers were coming across discarded syringes and the risks for staff who had to clear them up. Melbourne now routinely offers a disposal bin service to businesses.

Though theoretically possible, Especially in the case of hepatitis B, least so in respect of HIV. in practice acquisition of a blood-borne virus infection due to a needlestick injury from a discarded syringe is virtually unheard of. In Australia, no such incidents have been recorded. Yet the fear that this might happen is real enough and so is the environmental degradation caused by discards and the negative impression they give of injecting drug users. Despite there being no evidence that discards increase when a needle exchange opens, such concerns mean that discards jeopardise public support for facilities serving injectors, especially needle exchanges. Indirectly, this makes discards an important public health issue because opposition may threaten viral control via exchanges.

Current UK government guidance acknowledges these points and potential public hostility to bins, before calling on local partnerships to "fully explore the potential for sharps bins", and in particular to ensure their effective promotion and siting. Though there is no specific call to consider non-public premises, this general recommendation would legitimise a move beyond the usual siting in public toilets. Such initiatives could build on the trend in the UK to persuade private premises managers such as pub landlords to make their toilets accessible to the public. As with that initiative, it has the potential to greatly increase access to facilities (in this case, syringe disposal bins) at relatively little cost.

Last revised 29 December 2008

Comment/query to editor
Give us your feedback on the site (one-minute survey)
Open Effectiveness Bank home page
Add your name to the mailing list to be alerted to new studies and other site updates


Top 10 most closely related documents on this site. For more try a subject or free text search

DOCUMENT 2010 Consideration of the use of foil, as an intervention, to reduce the harms of injecting heroin and cocaine

STUDY 2008 Distributing foil from needle and syringe programmes (NSPs) to promote transitions from heroin injecting to chasing: an evaluation

HOT TOPIC 2016 Time for safer injecting spaces in Britain?

STUDY 2003 'Most compelling evidence yet' that injecting rooms reduce overdose deaths

STUDY 2012 A comparison of syringe disposal practices among injection drug users in a city with versus a city without needle and syringe programs

MATRIX CELL 2014 Drug Matrix cell C1: Management/supervision: Reducing harm

MATRIX CELL 2014 Drug Matrix cell E1: Local and national systems; Reducing harm

MATRIX CELL 2014 Drug Matrix cell A1: Interventions; Reducing harm

MATRIX CELL 2014 Drug Matrix cell D1: Organisational functioning; Reducing harm

STUDY 2014 Self-reported changes in drug use behaviors and syringe disposal methods following the opening of a supervised injecting facility in Copenhagen, Denmark