Send email for updates


About updates
Research analysis

This entry is our analysis of a study added to the Effectiveness Bank. The original study was not published by Findings; click Title to order a copy. Free reprints may be available from the authors – click prepared e-mail. Links to other documents. Hover over for notes. Click to highlight passage referred to. Unfold extra text Unfold supplementary text The Summary conveys the findings and views expressed in the study.

Title and link for copying Comment/query to editor

The role of ethnic matching between patient and provider on the effectiveness of brief alcohol interventions with Hispanics.

Field C.A., Caetano R.
Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research: 2010, 34(2), p. 262–271.
Unable to obtain a copy by clicking title? Try asking the author for a reprint by adapting this prepared e-mail or by writing to Dr Field at craig.field@austin.utexas.edu. You could also try this alternative source.

At a US emergency department, a brief conversation about the pros and cons of their risky drinking and offers of support for any efforts to reduce harm led to extra reductions in the drinking of Hispanic patients which were greatest when they were matched to a Hispanic and Spanish-speaking counsellor.

Summary Background Evaluating the effectiveness of treatments such as brief alcohol interventions among Hispanics is essential to effectively addressing their treatment needs. Clinicians of the same ethnicity as the client may be more likely to understand the culture-specific values, norms, and attitudes and, therefore, the intervention may be more effective. Thus, in cases in which Hispanic patients were provided an intervention by a Hispanic clinician, improved drinking outcomes were expected.

Methods Patients were recruited from an urban Level 1 Trauma centre following screening for an alcohol-related injury or alcohol problems. 537 Hispanics were randomly assigned to brief intervention or treatment as usual. Hierarchical linear modelling was used to determine the effects of ethnic match on drinking outcomes, including volume per week, maximum amount, and frequency of five or more drinks per occasion. Analyses controlled for level of acculturation and immigration status.

Results For Hispanics who received brief motivational intervention, an ethnic match between patient and provider resulted in a significant reduction in drinking outcomes at the 12-month follow-up. In addition, there was a tendency for ethnic match to be most beneficial to foreign-born Hispanics and less acculturated Hispanics.

Conclusions As hypothesised, an ethnic match between patient and provider significantly enhanced the effectiveness of brief intervention among Hispanics. Ethnic concordance between patient and provider may have impacted the effectiveness of the intervention through several mechanisms including cultural scripts, According to the featured study, "Cultural scripts are patterns of social interaction that are a core characteristic of a particular cultural group. More than being indicative of personal values, cultural scripts are values and beliefs that characterise a particular culture or ethnic group. As a result, the potential impact of attending to these cultural scripts and cultural norms likely extends beyond empathy, which is a core component of interventions based on motivational interviewing. In contrast to interventions based on motivational interviewing, in the treatment as usual condition there was no opportunity to convey appreciation and understanding of cultural scripts through the use of reflections, communication of empathy or examination of personal values." ethnic-specific perceptions pertaining to substance abuse, and ethnic-specific preferred channels of communication.

For other reports on this trial see these Findings entries: Ethnic differences in drinking outcomes following a brief alcohol intervention in the trauma care setting; The effectiveness of brief intervention among injured patients with alcohol dependence: who benefits from brief interventions?.

Last revised 20 January 2011

Comment/query to editor
Give us your feedback on the site (one-minute survey)
Open Effectiveness Bank home page
Add your name to the mailing list to be alerted to new studies and other site updates


Top 10 most closely related documents on this site. For more try a subject or free text search

STUDY 2010 The effectiveness of brief intervention among injured patients with alcohol dependence: who benefits from brief interventions?

STUDY 2010 Ethnic differences in drinking outcomes following a brief alcohol intervention in the trauma care setting

STUDY 2012 Alcohol screening and brief intervention in emergency departments

STUDY 2014 The effectiveness of alcohol screening and brief intervention in emergency departments: a multicentre pragmatic cluster randomized controlled trial

STUDY 2009 Counselor skill influences outcomes of brief motivational interventions

STUDY 2014 A multisite randomized controlled trial of brief intervention to reduce drinking in the trauma care setting: how brief is brief?

STUDY 2010 What process research tells us about brief intervention efficacy

STUDY 2010 The impact of screening, brief intervention and referral for treatment in emergency department patients' alcohol use: a 3-, 6- and 12-month follow-up

STUDY 2010 Screening, Brief Intervention, and Referral to Treatment (SBIRT): 12-month outcomes of a randomized controlled clinical trial in a Polish emergency department

REVIEW 2012 Screening, brief intervention, and referral for alcohol use in adolescents: a systematic review