Send email for updates

About updates
Review analysis

This entry is our analysis of a review or synthesis of research findings considered particularly relevant to improving outcomes from drug or alcohol interventions in the UK. The original review was not published by Findings; click Title to order a copy. Links to other documents. Hover over for notes. Click to highlight passage referred to. Unfold extra text Unfold supplementary text The Summary conveys the findings and views expressed in the review. Below is a commentary from Drug and Alcohol Findings.

Title and link for copying Comment/query to editor

The search for medications to treat stimulant dependence.

Kampman K.M.
Addiction Science and Clinical Practice: 2008, 4(2), p. 28–35.
Unable to obtain a copy by clicking title? Try this alternative source.

Expert and accessible review of the state of play in finding effective and (to the patients) acceptable medications to initiate or sustain abstinence from cocaine or methamphetamine. Though extensive, the results of this US-led search have so far been disappointing.

Summary Progress in understanding the neurobiology of stimulant dependence has enabled researchers to identify medications whose pharmacological effects suggest they might help patients initiate abstinence or avoid relapse. Several of these medications and a vaccine have shown encouraging results in controlled clinical trials with cocaine-dependent patients, though none has yet been approved in the USA for treating stimulant dependence.

Patients who experience severe cocaine withdrawal symptoms are twice as likely to drop out of treatment and less likely to attain abstinence in outpatient programmes. The most promising medication for initiating abstinence is modafinil, currently approved for the treatment of narcolepsy and itself a mild stimulant. The latest trial involved 210 cocaine-dependent patients who took 200mg or 400mg modafinil daily, or a placebo. Among patients dependent only on cocaine, both dosages of modafinil were superior to placebo for promoting abstinence, but this was not the case among the 41% also dependent on alcohol. Propranolol has also shown promise. For sustaining (as opposed to initiating) abstinence, promising GABAergic medications Cocaine causes euphoria and reinforcement by raising dopamine levels in the mesocortical reward system. One potential way to counterbalance this effect is to elevate mesocortical levels of gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA), a neurotransmitter that pushes dopamine levels downward by inhibiting the activity of dopaminergic (dopamine-releasing) neurones. Preclinical trials have suggested that GABAergic compounds promote GABA release or conservation. include gamma-vinyl GABA (GVG), tiagabine, and topiramate.

Disulfiram (Antabuse) is a promising cocaine relapse prevention medication with a unique mechanism of action. Its effects lead to extremely high cocaine and dopamine levels when cocaine is ingested, making the high less pleasant by increasing associated anxiety. Four published trials have demonstrated that disulfiram reduces cocaine use in cocaine-dependent patients. Another promising option being explored is the 'vaccine' TA-CD. It works by stimulating the production of cocaine-specific antibodies which bind to cocaine molecules and prevent them crossing the blood–brain barrier.

The search for a medical treatment for methamphetamine dependence started more recently. At least one candidate medication has shown promise in early clinical testing. Bupropion is an antidepressant which supports positive mood by inhibiting the reuptake of dopamine into cells, leaving more of the neurotransmitter circulating in the brain. The same mechanism may be helpful in easing the negative mood symptoms of methamphetamine withdrawal. In a recent trial involving 151 methamphetamine-dependent patients, bupropion recipients (especially those whose methamphetamine use at baseline was less intensive) had somewhat better abstinence outcomes compared with placebo.

Treatment approaches combining efficacious medications and proven behavioural interventions will almost certainly produce the best results. Among the latter is voucher-based reinforcement therapy, a form of contingency management which rewards patients who achieve predetermined therapeutic goals with vouchers redeemable for goods and services.

All the trials to date have been relatively small, so the efficacy and safety of these medications has not been definitively established. Also, most have primarily included men. Although no medications are currently proven to be effective, it is hoped that effective pharmacological treatments for stimulant dependence will soon become available.

Findings logo commentary Arguably this useful, accessible and well organised review leans towards a 'glass half full' (and soon may be fuller) interpretation of the evidence. As the author acknowledges, stopping stimulant use is much less of a problem (in fact, it occurs naturally even in dependent users) than staying stopped. The bind relapse-prevention medications are in, is that either they are not effective, or if they are, patients will simply stop taking them once they have recovered from the unpleasant consequences of overdoing stimulants to the point where they want to re-experience the highs. Hence the interest in long-acting solutions such as vaccines; the decision to take these can be made at a time when motivation (or coercive pressure) is high, and they remain a restraining influence when motivation wanes. The hope is that this period will embed the habit of non-use. But even these may require the motivation to repeat the procedure once the vaccine wears off. As has been remarked, if the patient has sufficient resolve to keep taking medications, they are probably also well on the way to succeeding in any sort of treatment, whether or not it involves medications. There is also the risk that other drugs not blocked by the vaccine will be substituted for cocaine.

The featured review argues that psychosocial therapies are inadequate due to high drop-out rates, but the same can be said of medication-based programmes. For the reasons given above, few trials have both retained patients in compliance with the medication regimen, and at the same time restrained their stimulant use. Combining medication with rewards for abstinence and/or complying with treatment can help initiate abstinence, but it is unclear whether these gains are typically sustained.

Another recent but more technical overall review of medications for cocaine dependence recently reached similar conclusions. Other recent reviews and meta-analyses A study which uses recognised procedures to summarise quantitative results from several studies of the same or similar interventions to arrive at composite outcome scores. Usually undertaken to allow the intervention's effectiveness to be assessed with greater confidence than on the basis of the studies taken individually. include one of antipsychotic medications in the treatment of cocaine dependence, which found no evidence to support their clinical use. A similar verdict was reached in respect of anticonvulsants and prescribing other stimulants (a variety of substitution treatment).

Prompted by decades of cocaine-dominated drug problems, development of medications to counter these has been a top priority for the US government, which has funded the testing of over 60 marketed medications. Though extensive and persistent, the results of this US-led search have so far been disappointing. However, hopes remain high in some quarters and the search continues. Caution is required because all medications have side-effects, and some of those currently being considered for treating stimulant dependence can have severe consequences. Until risks and costs are clearly balanced by benefits, doctors and patients cannot be advised to consider routine use of any of the candidate medications. In the meantime, European clinicians prefer to rely mostly on psychosocial interventions to reduce cocaine-related problems.

Last revised 10 July 2009. First uploaded 03 July 2009

Comment/query to editor
Give us your feedback on the site (one-minute survey)
Open Effectiveness Bank home page
Add your name to the mailing list to be alerted to new studies and other site updates

Top 10 most closely related documents on this site. For more try a subject or free text search

STUDY 2010 Review of treatment for cocaine dependence

REVIEW 2012 BAP updated guidelines: evidence-based guidelines for the pharmacological management of substance abuse, harmful use, addiction and comorbidity: recommendations from BAP

REVIEW 2009 Traditional medicine in the treatment of drug addiction

STUDY 2012 Double-blind placebo-controlled evaluation of the PROMETATM protocol for methamphetamine dependence

DOCUMENT 2013 Rewarding virtue

HOT TOPIC 2016 Should we offer prizes for not using drugs?

REVIEW 2009 The state of pharmacotherapy for the treatment of alcohol dependence

REVIEW 2004 Take the network into treatment

REVIEW 2010 A review of opioid dependence treatment: pharmacological and psychosocial interventions to treat opioid addiction

REVIEW 2009 Efficacy of opiate maintenance therapy and adjunctive interventions for opioid dependence with comorbid cocaine use disorders: a systematic review and meta-analysis of controlled clinical trials